Paying a water bill on a city website takes most people a few clicks. For a resident who is blind and uses a screen reader or software that reads a page aloud, the same task can stop at a "Pay now" button the software announces as nothing at all.
For millions of Americans, city websites are where everyday business with local government happens: paying utility bills and parking tickets, applying for permits and checking meeting agendas. More than 1 in 4 U.S. adults have some type of disability, according to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention. When a city website doesn't work with the tools they use, a five-minute errand can turn into a phone call, a trip to City Hall, or a request for someone else's help.
A July 2026 scan of large U.S. city government websites by AccessLumens, a company that sells accessibility testing, found that about 4 in 10 had at least one critical barrier. The finding comes as a federal deadline approaches: by April 26, 2027, large state and local governments must make their websites and mobile apps accessible to people with disabilities.
Clym reviewed federal rulemaking, independent accessibility research and a 2026 scan of big-city government websites to examine how easy those websites are for residents with disabilities to use.
AccessLumens scored 158 city government websites, mostly in cities of 100,000 or more residents. It tested each city's homepage and, where possible, a page residents use to pay a bill, apply for a permit or contact the city.
The average score was 93 out of 100, but a good score didn't mean every resident could get through. Of the 158 websites scored:
The scan relied on automated software and scripted keyboard tests. These catch many common problems but not all, and they don't observe real people using a website. AccessLumens calls its results "a diagnostic snapshot, not a legal conformance determination," and it does not name individual cities.
Wider research shows the same pattern. WebAIM, a nonprofit at Utah State University, scanned the home pages of the 1 million most visited websites in early 2026 and found detectable accessibility failures on 95.9% of them.
Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act requires state and local governments to make their services accessible to people with disabilities. A Justice Department rule now spells out what that means online: government websites and mobile apps must meet the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1, Level AA. It covers things like text descriptions on images, forms that work without a mouse and buttons a screen reader can identify.
Governments serving 50,000 or more people have until April 26, 2027. Smaller governments and special district governments have until April 26, 2028, under the department's April 2026 rule, which moved both dates back a year without changing the standard. The requirements reach beyond city hall to public services such as transit agencies, libraries, and public colleges.
The rule includes a few narrow exceptions, such as certain archived content and older documents that are no longer in use. Even when an exception applies, governments still have a broader duty under the ADA to communicate effectively with residents with disabilities.
Even among these large cities, size made a difference. In the AccessLumens scan, 44% of cities with 100,000 to 250,000 residents had a critical barrier, compared with 13% of the eight cities with more than 1 million. The report notes that mid-size cities often have the fewest staff dedicated to accessibility.
Smaller cities often have fewer people and less money to maintain their websites. In its rule, the Justice Department said: "staff resources and availability continue to pose significant challenges." Clarence Anthony, CEO and executive director of the National League of Cities, said the extra year "balances the needs of residents with disabilities with the budgetary realities of local governments."
Technology can also make a difference. When an accessibility problem is built into the software behind a city's website, the same issue can appear across many pages. That can make problems harder to address without changes to the underlying system.
Unlike a store, a city has no competitor to switch to. The American Association of People with Disabilities points to public benefits applications, emergency alerts and voter information as services that are increasingly moving online.
The people affected go well beyond those who are blind. About 1 in 20 U.S. adults has serious difficulty seeing even with glasses, and more than 1 in 8 has serious difficulty concentrating, remembering or making decisions, according to the CDC. Older residents whose eyesight or dexterity is changing can run into the same problems with low-contrast text, tiny buttons or forms that time out.
Maria Town, president and CEO of the American Association of People with Disabilities, called the one-year delay "a profound disappointment and a serious setback for the disability community," saying disabled people continue to be shut out of digital systems that serve as gateways to government information and services.
If you can't finish a form, read an important notice or complete a payment on a government website, you don't have to wait until 2027 to speak up. Governments already must make their services accessible.
It also helps to know what to look for. The most common problems in the AccessLumens scan were text with too little color contrast to read easily (28% of cities), images with no text description (22%), links that don't say where they lead (13%) and controls that can't be reached with a keyboard (11%).
Reporting an accessibility barrier can help a city identify what needs fixing, not just for one person, but for everyone who depends on that service. Whether someone is paying a water bill, applying for a permit or looking for public information, access to local government shouldn't depend on their ability to use a mouse or read a screen.
This story was produced by Clym and reviewed and distributed by Stacker.